The Big House Toronto, Ontario 41 Mystic Ave.

you're thinking…"WTF?!!" That first impression shows the true importance of curb appeal. this house doesn't have any. But look closer. fresh paint, new windows…step inside. This house is fire!

This is exactly the kind of house you rehab when you absolutely have to live in that hot downtown neighborhood, but you really can’t afford it. This house is one most people would drive by without even noticing it. But it’s a testament to what good design is all about. Someone took this fugly little house and turned it into a dream home. By creatively using the available space and a small budget, this tiny house is actually two separate residences, with two kitchens, two laundry rooms, and two separate entrances. It’s being leased out as apartments, but the lower living area looks more like a mother-in-law suite to me. Clearly, it needs more work. There’s no landscaping, and that pile of bricks passing for a porch needs demolition. But this was a brilliant use of a small budget, putting the money going where you’re actually gonna live…on the inside. 

Play Video

Amenities

LISTED FOR: $50,000,000

In My Opinion…

This house defies the laws of quantum physics. It’s like Snoopy’s doghouse, tiny on the outside, but enormous on the inside. If you were looking to buy a home, the neighborhood alone might be enough to scare you away. But this house is proof that looks are deceiving. Someone saw this house and realized that it had “good bones”. They brought it up to code, and used the rest of the budget putting luxury finishes in it. I don’t think I could do the neighborhood, but the house itself…I’d move in tomorrow if it was available. Especially if I could have the whole house and not just an apartment. This is so well designed, I don’t know what I’d do with all the extra space!

I hardly know where to begin, but I’m gonna start with the killer color palette they decided on: Black and white. They didn’t stage the house, which was a stroke of genius because you really get a feel for how much space they made out of basically nothing. That black and white color palette means that pretty much any way you furnish it is gonna work. But more importantly, the white adds volume, making every room look way bigger. The pops of black add just enough contrast to the space to keep it from looking sterile or bland. It’s just black, white, and hickory woodwork, everywhere you look. 

And can we talk about all the woodwork?!! The wooden slat feature walls, the matching bench seating in the foyer and kitchen, the matching live-edge barn doors and stair treads, and the matching wall-to-wall hardwood floors? Honey please…you had me at hardwood floors! The cool thing about all the hickory is that it really warms up all that white. There’s no such thing as too much natural light to me, but there’s so much of it flowing through all those wonderful, weatherproofed windows that without the hickory, the house would feel cold, especially with the curtains open exposing all the snow outside, which is just part of living in Canada. That’s a lot of wood, and it really gives the house a cozy, homey feel that draws you into the house and invites you to explore.

But what really blew me away is that this house has not one, not two but three levels to it. Like I said, it’s Snoopy’s doghouse. It’s Harry Potter’s tent. It looks like there’s barely room for one person. But that’s a four-bedroom house. From the outside, it doesn’t look like it has an upstairs, but it does. And it’s big enough to have not one but nice-sized bedrooms. What I didn’t see in the video were closets. Which isn’t surprising because houses like that weren’t built for people with lots of clothes. They were built for poor folk. 

As for the backyard, it’s got loads of potential. But potential is all it’s gonna have until they tear down that fugly assed shed. That would be a great start, but it’s gonna take a lot more than that to save that backyard space. The next time I got my hands on some money, I’ve build myself a tall wooden fence to shut out every possible view of my neighbors. And forget landscaping. After tearing down that shed and fencing it in, I’d lay down bricks or pavers so there’s no grass to cut, and maybe set up a little water feature to create a little outdoor zen. I’d set up a barbecue pit, a bar, and I’d get some killer patio furniture, and make myself an outdoor living and dining space that would make my house the party spot in the spring and summer.

Big House Rating:
4.1/5

Walk the Neighborhood

You’re gonna have to walk the neighborhood to make up your mind about this one. Click that box in the upper right-hand corner of the street view window to see what I mean. It’s not the worst neighborhood I’ve ever seen. In fact, it seems to be a fairly nice area. Thing is, they make a point on the website of noting that the house has a really good security system, which is a big red flag to the Chicagoan in me. When a house this tiny in a modest neighborhood has a really good burglar alarm on it, it would seem to suggest that burglary is not out of the realm of possibility in this area, and may actually be a bit of a problem. But I like to think of this home’s location and lack of curb appeal like I do my 20-year-old Maxima. It’s unimpressive exterior really works to my advantage. It’s a sweet ride with a stick, that I routinely drive at 90 mph on the highway with no problem. But it looks like a 20-year-old Maxima. Car thieves walk right past my ride, because clearly I’ve got nothing worth stealing…or so they think. This home looks like a million dollars on the inside, but the outside practically screams “nothing to steal here”.

LOCATION: 41 Mystic Ave. • Toronto, Ontario